Ninja Coffee Maker CM371: Which Brew Fits Your Mug?

The black Ninja CM371 is worth considering for its glass carafe, permanent filter, and four brew styles. We would choose the Ninja GP161 instead when documented support for both grounds and pods is the deciding requirement.

KitchenCog8 min readPublished

Short answer: Choose Travel Mug on this Ninja coffee maker for a 16 fl oz mug. The table below gives CM371’s published brew yields. Buy it if you brew ground coffee and switch between a single mug and a full carafe. If pods are part of your routine, choose the Ninja DualBrew GP161.

KitchenCog earns a commission from qualifying purchases made through links marked “Paid link”, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

On this page

Short answer: Choose Travel Mug on this Ninja coffee maker for a 16 fl oz mug. The table below gives CM371’s published brew yields. Buy it if you brew ground coffee and switch between a single mug and a full carafe. If pods are part of your routine, choose the Ninja DualBrew GP161.

Black Ninja CM371 coffee maker with its glass carafe.Image: SharkNinja

Where to buy

  • For switching between a mug and a full carafeNinja Hot & Iced XL Coffee Maker CM371 (Black, 12-Cup Glass Carafe)See on Amazon

The black CM371 and its included glass carafe.

Which Ninja coffee maker setting fits your mug?

In the Classic and Rich instructions, Ninja specifies a 16 fl oz (about 473 mL) vessel for Travel Mug and a 20 fl oz (about 591 mL) vessel for XL. Follow the larger vessel requirement even if you plan to use Rich, which dispenses less than Classic.

Check a mug you already own. Use a measuring jug to pour the required capacity of water into the mug, then check that its lid can close without spilling. Keep the setting whose vessel requirement your mug meets. Use the table below to decide how much coffee that setting actually serves.

These are the CM371 owner’s guide estimates for liquid dispensed, in US fluid ounces.

Dial setting Classic Rich Over Ice Cold Brew
Travel Mug 14.0 12.0 5.9 5.9
XL Travel Mug 18.3 15.9 7.6 7.6
Full Carafe 54.4 47.2 22.4 22.4

Approximate brew yields for both travel-mug settings on the Ninja CM371.Chart

Ninja’s CM371 manual gives the output estimates and separate minimum vessel capacities.

For a hot mug, choose Classic for a larger serving. Ninja’s troubleshooting guide recommends Rich if the coffee tastes too weak. For either cold setting, fill the receiving vessel with ice before brewing and put only water in the reservoir. The brewing instructions allow the included Ninja glass carafe for cold modes. Use a non-glass vessel otherwise. Ninja notes that some ice can melt during the brew. Use the manual’s ice and vessel instructions when choosing a cold setting.

Who should buy the black CM371?

The black CM371 is a good fit for someone who takes a mug on weekdays and makes a hot carafe for guests. It includes a 12-cup glass carafe, a permanent filter and a Ninja Smart Scoop. Keep the glass carafe off burners and out of ovens and microwaves. Keep it off wet or cold surfaces while it is hot, as the carafe instructions specify. If you rely on pods when you are short on time, the Ninja DualBrew GP161 accepts grounds and pods. Both product pages list the same four brew styles. The GP161 adds a pod workflow.

The CM371 brews ground coffee. If you buy whole beans, you will need a separate grinder. Ninja’s operating warnings rule out fine or espresso-ground coffee. The troubleshooting page recommends a medium grind. Fine grounds or too much coffee can clog the bottom of the filter holder and cause the brew basket to overflow. If you make lattes or cappuccinos most days, the Breville Bambino Plus is built for espresso shots and has an automatic steam wand for milk. Read about the milk-steaming workflow or see KitchenCog’s beginner espresso machine guide. SharkNinja lists the machine at 14.25 in long, 11.14 in wide and 17.4 in high (about 36.2 × 28.3 × 44.2 cm). Check that your outlet meets the listed 120 V requirement. Measure the full spot on an open counter and leave room to handle the reservoir and carafe. Follow the manual’s placement instructions.

Pros and cons

Pros

  • The marked mug and carafe settings let you pick a serving size for each brew instead of making a full pot every time.
  • The included permanent filter is a reusable option. Classic and Rich suit hot coffee, while the two cold settings brew into ice.

Cons

  • If you depend on pods, buy a brewer designed for them. Whole-bean users need a separate grinder.
  • The CM371 suits drip coffee. If your everyday drink needs espresso and steamed milk, budget counter space for a different setup.
  • A standard travel mug and the XL setting require different vessel sizes, even when the listed yield looks small enough.

How it compares with the Ninja DualBrew GP161

Buying factor Ninja CM371 Ninja DualBrew GP161
Coffee input Ground coffee in a filter basket Ground coffee or pods
Brew styles Classic, Rich, Over Ice and Cold Brew Classic, Rich, Over Ice and Cold Brew
Glass carafe and filter supplies listed in the box 12-cup glass carafe and permanent filter 12-cup glass carafe and paper filter kit
Dimensions (L × W × H, rounded to 0.1 in) 14.3 × 11.1 × 17.4 in 10.1 × 10.7 × 15.5 in

Choose the CM371 if you brew ground coffee and expect to use a washable filter. The GP161 specification lists pod settings from 6 to 12 fl oz. Choose the GP161 if one person brews a pot from grounds and another wants a smaller pod serving. On a shallow counter, compare the listed length and height in the table before you choose. Allow space to reach the parts on either machine. The CM371 yield table applies to that model only.

Filter use and cleanup

At high altitude, follow Ninja’s calibration instructions before the first brew. For the first-use rinse, fill the reservoir to the Full line with water and leave the filter holder free of grounds. Select Full Carafe and press Classic once, then discard the water when the cycle ends. See the first-use instructions.

The included permanent filter saves you from using a fresh paper filter on each brew. If you switch to paper, Ninja’s filter instructions say to remove the permanent filter first.

Compare your weekday serving before you compare cost

A CM371 Travel Mug on Classic yields about 14.0 fl oz according to the manual. The GP161’s listed pod settings top out at 12 oz. If you usually finish the larger serving, use grounds on both machines for a like-for-like cost comparison. If you are happy with the smaller serving, compare the price per pod with the cost of the grounds you weigh for that serving. For grounds, multiply the price per gram on your bag by the dose you use. Add a paper filter to the cost when you use one.

Ninja’s care instructions say to let the machine cool before removing the filter holder. Wash the permanent filter, glass carafe and lid with warm, soapy water. When the CLEAN light comes on, follow the manual’s descaling directions and allow about 60–75 minutes for the cycle. Leave the carafe in place until the cycle finishes, then empty it completely before running a Full Carafe Classic brew with plain water to flush the brewer.

FAQ

How much coffee does the full Ninja CM371 carafe make?

The CM371 brew-volume table gives these approximate Full Carafe yields in US fluid ounces: Classic 54.4, Rich 47.2, Over Ice 22.4 and Cold Brew 22.4.

Do Over Ice and Cold Brew fill the same amount?

The owner’s guide gives the same approximate liquid yields for these two modes at each size in the table. Use the cold-mode vessel and ice instructions above for either setting.

Method and sources

KitchenCog compared the CM371 owner’s guide, the CM371 product specification and the GP161 product specification. The volumes are manufacturer estimates. KitchenCog did not test either machine.

More from KitchenCog